Tobacco reviews top twenty lists

Because I have the tools and the interest, I grabbed the data from the excellent http://www.tobaccoreviews.com/ site and created tables for the top twenty blends in term of number of reviews, overall rating, and how many people specified a blend as their favorite. As always, be care with the data — some highly rated blends have only a single review for instance. Here are the tables. First, sorted by number of reviews.

Blend #reviews rating #favs
Full Virginia Flake 468 3.5 87
Nightcap 463 3.5 67
My Mixture 965 460 3.2 64
Squadron Leader 421 3.4 72
Early Morning Pipe 412 3.1 52
Penzance 393 3.5 49
Prince Albert 393 2.9 28
Regular 375 2.6 20
1792 Flake 342 3 40
Golden Sliced (Red) 331 3.3 50
Carter Hall 326 3 32
Escudo Navy De Luxe 321 3.4 69
University Flake 316 2.9 38
Frog Morton (Craftsbury Series) 312 3.2 45
Irish Flake 306 3.3 49
Royal Yacht 292 2.9 20
Erinmore Flake 283 2.8 26
Mixture Scottish Blend 270 2.8 23
Half & Half 268 2.1 6
Haddo’s Delight (Original Mixtures) 248 3 19
Navy Flake 246 3 31

Sorted by rating.

Blend #reviews rating #favs
Our Best Blend 16 4 5
HH Old Dark Fired Ready-Rubbed 15 4 2
Irishman’s 5 O’Clock (Reserve Pipe Tobaccos) 10 4 0
HH Bold Kentucky 9 4 4
No. 1 8 4 0
Great Hiatus 8 4 0
Guy’s Favorite 7 4 0
Edward G. (Original Warehouseblend) 7 4 2
Summertime Blend 2014 (Limited Edition) 7 4 0
Tarek Robusto 197 7 4 0
Gentleman’s Mixture Original 7 4 0
Holker Twist 7 4 3
Danish Slices 6 4 1
Reserve #21 6 4 0
Balkan Sobranie Match 6 4 2
Fayyum (Foundation by musico) 6 4 0
Nashville County (Original Warehouseblend) 6 4 1
Z50 Black Cordial 6 4 0
Original Virginia Flake 5 4 0
Balkan (Full) No. 1 (Okanagan Pipe Club) 5 4 1

Finally, sorted by number of people who have them as their favorite.

Blend #reviews rating #favs
Full Virginia Flake 468 3.5 87
Squadron Leader 421 3.4 72
Escudo Navy De Luxe 321 3.4 69
Nightcap 463 3.5 67
My Mixture 965 460 3.2 64
Early Morning Pipe 412 3.1 52
Golden Sliced (Red) 331 3.3 50
Penzance 393 3.5 49
Irish Flake 306 3.3 49
656: Aged Burley Flake 156 3.5 45
Frog Morton (Craftsbury Series) 312 3.2 45
1792 Flake 342 3 40
University Flake 316 2.9 38
Best Brown Flake 232 3.4 37
Westminster (Heirloom Collection) 219 3.4 37
Skiff Mixture 145 3.4 34
Hal O’ the Wynd (British Collection) 210 3.3 32
Presbyterian Mixture 189 3.2 32
Carter Hall 326 3 32
Three Oaks Syrian (Collector Series) 74 3.6 31

Leave a Reply